NDM4930 Welsh
Conservatives Debate - Motion without
amendment
(7/3/2012 -
18:04:15)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
Against |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
Against |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
Against |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
Against |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
Against |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
Against |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
Against |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
Against |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
Against |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
Against |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
Against |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
Against |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
Against |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
Against |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
Against |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
Against |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
For |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
For |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
For |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
For |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
For |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
Against |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
Against |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
Against |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
Against |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
Against |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
Against |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
Against |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
Against |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
Against |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
Against |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
Against |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
For |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
For |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
For |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
For |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
For: 13
Abstain: 0
Against: 40
Total: 53
NDM4930
Amendment 1
(7/3/2012 -
18:04:47)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
Against |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
Against |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
For: 27
Abstain: 0
Against: 26
Total: 53
NDM4930
Amendment 2
(7/3/2012 -
18:05:10)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
For |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
For |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
For |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
For |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
For |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
For |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
For |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
For |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
For |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
Total: 53
NDM4930
Amendment 3
(7/3/2012 -
18:05:29)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
Against |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
Against |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
For: 32
Abstain: 0
Against: 21
Total: 53
NDM4930
Amendment 4
(7/3/2012 -
18:05:52)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
Against |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
Against |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
For: 27
Abstain: 0
Against: 26
Total: 53
NDM4930
Amendment 7
(7/3/2012 -
18:06:18)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
Against |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
Against |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
For: 32
Abstain: 0
Against: 21
Total: 53
NDM4930 Welsh
Conservatives Debate - Motion as
amended
(7/3/2012 -
18:06:35)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
Against |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
Against |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
For: 27
Abstain: 0
Against: 26
Total: 53
NDM4931 Plaid
Cymru Debate - Motion without
amendment
(7/3/2012
- 18:07:04)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
Against |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
Against |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
Against |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
Against |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
Against |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
Against |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
Against |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
Against |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
Against |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
Against |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
Against |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
Against |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
Against |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
Against |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
Against |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
Against |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
Against |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
Against |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
Against |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
Against |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
Against |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
Against |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
Against |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
Against |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
Against |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
Against |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
Against |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
Against |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
Against |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
Total: 53
NDM4931
Amendment 1
(7/3/2012 -
18:07:22)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
For |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
Against |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
Against |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
For: 33
Abstain: 0
Against: 20
Total: 53
NDM4931
Amendment 2
(7/3/2012 -
18:07:38)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
For |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
For |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
For |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
For |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
For |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
For |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
For |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
For |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
For |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
Total: 53
NDM4931
Amendment 3
(7/3/2012 -
18:07:54)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
Against |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
Against |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
Against |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
Against |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
Against |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
Against |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
Against |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
Against |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
Against |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
Against |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
Against |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
Against |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
Against |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
Against |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
Against |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
Against |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
For |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
For |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
For |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
For |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
For |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
Against |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
Against |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
Against |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
Against |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
Against |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
Against |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
Against |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
Against |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
Against |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
Against |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
Against |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
Against |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
For |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
For |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
For |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
For |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
For: 12
Abstain: 0
Against: 41
Total: 53
NDM4931
Amendment 4
(7/3/2012 -
18:08:12)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
For |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
For |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
For |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
For |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
For |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
For |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
For |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
For |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
For |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
For |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
Total: 53
NDM4931
Amendment 5
(7/3/2012 -
18:08:28)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
For |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
Abstained |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
For: 41
Abstain: 12
Against: 0
Total: 53
NDM4931 Plaid
Cymru Debate - Motion as amended
(7/3/2012 -
18:08:46)
|
Name |
Political Party |
Vote |
|
Andrews, Leighton |
Labour |
For |
|
Sargeant, Carl |
Labour |
For |
|
Gregory, Janice |
Labour |
For |
|
Hutt, Jane |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Carwyn |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Hart, Edwina |
Labour |
For |
|
Lewis, Huw |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, Lesley |
Labour |
For |
|
Griffiths, John |
Labour |
For |
|
Black, Peter |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Williams, Kirsty |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Davies, Jocelyn |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Wyn Jones, Ieuan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jones, Elin |
Plaid Cymru |
Did not vote |
|
Ffed Jones, Alun |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Gwenda |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Alun |
Labour |
For |
|
Cuthbert, Jeff |
Labour |
For |
|
Mewies, Sandy |
Labour |
For |
|
Hedges, Mike |
Labour |
For |
|
Chapman, Christine |
Labour |
For |
|
Davies, Keith |
Labour |
For |
|
James, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Ramsay, Nick |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Millar, Darren |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Graham, William |
Conservative |
Against |
|
R T Davies, Andrew |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Paul |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Burns, Angela |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Roberts, Aled |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Parrott, Eluned |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Powell, William |
Liberal Democrat |
For |
|
Glyn Thomas, Rhodri |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Thomas, Simon |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Wood, Leanne |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Gruffydd, Llyr Huws |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Jenkins, Bethan |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Whittle, Lindsay |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Elis Thomas, Dafydd |
Plaid Cymru |
Against |
|
Rees, David |
Labour |
For |
|
Morgan, Julie |
Labour |
For |
|
Skates, Ken |
Labour |
For |
|
Antoniw, Mick |
Labour |
For |
|
Gething, Vaughan |
Labour |
For |
|
Watson, Joyce |
Labour |
For |
|
Jones, Ann |
Labour |
Did not vote |
|
Evans, Rebecca |
Labour |
For |
|
Neagle, Lynne |
Labour |
For |
|
Rathbone, Jenny |
Labour |
For |
|
Drakeford, Mark |
Labour |
For |
|
Price, Gwyn |
Labour |
For |
|
Isherwood, Mark |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Asghar, Mohammad (Oscar) |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Sandbach, Antoinette |
Conservative |
Against |
|
George, Russell |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Byron |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Finch-Saunders, Janet |
Conservative |
Against |
|
Davies, Suzy |
Conservative |
Did not vote |
For: 32
Abstain: 0
Against: 21
Total: 53